2015: Julio Cesar Davila (LA Galaxy)
2016: Allan Hall (D.C. United)
2017: Angelo Pulice (Vancouver Whitecaps)
2018: Matt Jackson and Brandon Adams (Atlanta United)
2019: Paul Pickett (Real Salt Lake)
2020: No award
2021: Dane Beaumont (Seattle Sounders)
2022: Ben Gutierrez (Minnesota United)
2023: Bryan Warman (FC Cincinnati)
2024: John Cowhey (Chicago Fire)
2025: Carlos Hernandez (LAFC)
Last updated: 12/31/2025